Folio · SPXSet Report · Digest
v0.7.0 STABLE · 2026-11-11 · r4

2026-W43 · Oct 19–Oct 25 · General · Digest · published

Index >>> General >>> Digest

Strike Breach vs IV Pop: Does the Source of a Loss Matter? — Julia Spina Study Digest

Strike Breach vs IV Pop: Does the Source of a Loss Matter?
Julia Spina (@FinancePhoton) · tasty research X Article · Jul 31, 2026
DIGEST
1× LOSS HIT RATE
27%
10 yrs, daily-opened
RECOVERY · IV POP
90.0%
highest recovery
RECOVERY · PUT BREACH
53.7%
~half
RECOVERY · CALL BREACH
21.9%
least likely

THE STUDY

  • 2016-01-01 → 2026-07-14 (10 years), short 20Δ 15 DTE SPY strangles, opened daily to maximize occurrences.
  • Loss source classified at the time of the loss: call breach, put breach, or neither (IV).
  • Recovery probability, avg/median P/L and CVaR calculated assuming the trade is closed as soon as P/L flips positive.
  • Results logged once daily at 2:45 PM — intraday activity not captured; read directionally, not as precise probabilities.

SOURCE OF 1×-CREDIT LOSSES — share of 1×-loss trades

SHORT 20Δ 15DTE SPY STRANGLE: SOURCE OF 1×-CREDIT LOSSES 2016-01-04 to 2026-07-14 · avg DTE remaining shown below 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 47.4% 44.0% 8.5% Call Breach Put Breach Neither (IV) 4.7 DTE left 6.7 DTE left 11.1 DTE left IV-driven losses happen early; breaches occur closer to expiration
Call breaches were the most common trigger; IV-driven losses were rare (8.5%) but happened earliest in the trade's life.

RECOVERY PROBABILITY BY LOSS SOURCE — conditional on hitting a 1×-credit loss

RECOVERY PROBABILITY BY LOSS SOURCE P(recovers by expiration) · 2016-01-04 to 2026-07-14 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% 21.9% 53.7% 90.0% Call Breach Put Breach Neither (IV) 50% line IV pops recover 9 in 10 — partly because they happen early, leaving time

FULL STATISTICS — recovery after a 1×-credit loss, by source

MetricCall BreachPut BreachNeither (IV)All
% of 1× losses47.4%44.0%8.5%100.0%
P(recovery)21.9%53.7%90.0%41.7%
Avg final P/L−$396.16−$406.24−$133.43−$378.14
Median final P/L−$305.00$12.00$35.25−$190.25
CVaR (worst 5%)−$1,745.59−$3,201.28−$3,383.33−$2,596.29
Call breaches: least likely to recover but least tail risk. Put breaches and IV pops: positive median P/L, but meaningfully higher tail risk.

WHAT IV-DRIVEN LOSSES TURN INTO — n = 60 trades

OutcomePut BreachCall BreachStayed Neither
% of IV-driven losses48.3%6.7%45.0%
CVaR (worst 5%)−$4,012.50−$286.50$1.25
Nearly half of IV-driven losses eventually evolved into put breaches — which is why their tail risk matches put-breach losses despite the 90% recovery rate.

TAKEAWAYS FOR PREMIUM SELLERS

1× losses occurred 27% of the time and recovered 42% overall — but the source of the loss significantly changed the odds.

Call breaches: most common, least likely to recover (22%), least tail risk — the decision to cut is more straightforward.

Put breaches: recovered about half the time, ~1.8× the tail risk of calls — waiting improves the median outcome but exposes you to a small number of much larger losses.

IV pops: 90% recovered, but tail risk comparable to put breaches — middle-ground approach: give them time until the put side is actually breached or another management threshold is hit.

Holding is also a capital-efficiency question — buying power tied up in a loser could be deployed into the next trade.

Source: tasty research X Article by Julia Spina (@FinancePhoton), Jul 31 2026. All figures transcribed verbatim; charts rebuilt from the article's stated values. Original: https://x.com/FinancePhoton/status/2082898371308663293
Previous · Is Your Losing Trade Coming Back? Here's What the Data Says — Julia Spina Study DigestNext · How Duration and IV Impact Strangle Decay — Julia Spina Study Digest

Entered 2026-10-04 03:21 · updated 2026-10-23 04:28 · rev 3